History
and Origins
A plant of many faces, St. John's wort
(Hypericum perforatum) is regarded as
wildflower, weed, and an herb. As a healthful plant
it has interested herbalists since the earliest
Greek herbals. The first century Greek physicians
Galen and Dioscorides recommended it as a diuretic,
wound healing herb, and a treatment for menstrual
disorders. In the sixteenth century Paracelsus, who
ushered in the era of mineral medicines, used St.
John's wort externally for treating wounds and for
allaying the pain of contusions.
In the Middle
Ages, remarkable, even mystical properties were bestowed
upon the herb. It was used as a talisman to protect
one from "demons." Harvesting herbs during Medieval
times meant collecting the herb on a specific day,
often a day with religious significance. Whether
the mention of a specific holy day was simply a
means by which to convey the best time of year to
harvest the herb, or whether it is believed that
collection on that day imbued the herbs with
greater power, is subject to speculation. St.
John's wort, as you might guess, is best harvested
on St. John's day (June 24th), which is often the
time of peak blooming. If a sprig of the herb were
placed under the pillow on St. John's Eve, St. John
himself may even appear in a dream, blessing the
dreamer for another year.
The name Hypericum derives
from the Greek name for the plant "hyperikon." The word
roots are hyper (meaning over) and eikon (meaning
image). Botanists from the time of Linnaeus, the father
of modern botanical science, have attempted to describe
the origins in various ways. One meaning translating to "almost over ghosts" refers
to mystical properties attributed to the plant from Medieval
times. The common name St. John's wort derives from
Anglo-Saxon tradition, when the plant was
considered to drive away evil spirits and ward off
the devil's temptations.
St. John's wort is native
to Europe, occurring throughout that continent,
except the extreme North. Hypericum is a large
genus with about 300 species. Hypericum
perforatum is a much-branched perennial herb
growing from one to three feet high. The leaves are
covered by translucent dots easily seen by holding
the leaves up to a light; these are the
perforations that give the plant its species
designation "perforatum". When the fresh
flowers are crushed, they exude a blood-red juice,
which stains the fingers blue-violet.
Herb
or Weed?
While St. John's wort is native to Europe, it
is naturalized in waste places and along roadsides
in Asia, Africa, North and South America and
Australia. It is one of those European native
plants that has followed European settlers wherever
they have traveled in the world. The plant was
introduced by early settlers to North America, and
by 1793, the first recorded specimen, grown without
cultivation, was collected in Pennsylvania.
Especially vigorous
populations in western North America and Australia
have made it a serious weed problem. It is
particularly aggressive in rangelands with dry
summers. Historically, the greatest economic
importance of the herb focuses on St. John's wort
as serious weed of rangelands in Europe, Asia,
North and South Africa, Australia, and eastern and
western North America. Its economic impact is
considered detrimental because it invaded pastures,
leaving them a blaze of yellow flowers. Most North
American scientific studies devoted to the plant
ironically have focused on how to eradicate the
plant. Despite its value as a medicinal plant,
eradication programs have been developed in Canada,
California and Australia to eliminate this invasive
foreigner. A natural enemy of the plant, the
Chrysolina beetle has been used in California and
introduced into Canada as a natural biological
control to kill the plant. Now interest is again
turning to how the herb can be used in
medicine.
Twentieth
Century Use
Given the superstitions surrounding the herb,
physicians had dismissed it as a folk medicine by
the mid-nineteenth century. Interest in the
medicinal uses of the plant was kept alive by
Eclectic medical practitioners in the United
States, who found it to be a useful wound healing
agent, especially for lacerations involving damage
to nerves, as well as a diuretic, astringent,
nervine, and mild sedative. A survey among
physicians conducted in 1938 by a German physician,
Dr. Gerhard Madaus, found that St. John's wort
preparations were being utilized for nerve
conditions, and disorders induced by "excessive
intellectual efforts." It was also being used for
neuroses, general restlessness and insomnia.
In Europe, St. John's wort
it is still widely used as a medicinal plant, in
home remedies and pharmacy products. A tea made
from the plant is popularly used as a mild nerve
tonic for the treatment of anxiety, depression,
insomnia, and general unrest. It is also used as a
diuretic, and for the treatment of gastritis.
Vegetable oil preparations of the flowers are used
externally for the treatment of hemorrhoids and
inflammation. According to Dr. Dennis Awang,
alcoholic tinctures and vegetable oil extracts of
the flowers are official remedies in the
pharmacopeias of eastern European countries such as
the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Poland, Romania,
Russia. Dr. Awang also writes that two preparations
are widely prescribed in Russia as antibacterials,
which are claimed to be more effective against Staphylococcus aureus than sulfanilamide
(sulfa drugs).
St.
John's Wort and Depression
In the past decade, most of the scientific
attention on St. John's wort and its preparations
has been to study its potential for use in the
treatment of mild to moderate forms of depression.
The preparations enhance mood over a long period of
time, generally not producing positive results for
at least two to three weeks, and often taking two
to three months before producing beneficial
results. This shows one of the general differences
traditionally recognized for herbal medicines. They
often take a relatively long period of time to
produce beneficial results compared with "magic
bullet" conventional medicines, whose effects are
often experienced immediately or within a few hours
of treatment.
How
it works
A number of recent studies have focused on the
pharmacological mechanisms and clinical use of St.
John's wort for the treatment of depression. A 1984
study by Suzuki and co-workers demonstrated that
hypericin, a red component abundant in the flowers
of St. John's wort, inhibited type A and type B
monoamine oxidase. Monoamine oxidase inhibitors
have been used for the treatment of depression
because they help to curb an enzyme that breaks
down monoamine, which is a precursor of
norepinephrine, a neurotransmitter.
Neurotransmitters carry nerve impulses through
particular nerve pathways. It has been suggested
that some types of clinical depression may results
from a decrease in the effectiveness of
neurotransmitters in the brain. Since hypericin was
shown to inhibit types A and B monoamine oxidase,
it was suggested as a possible basis for the
anti-depressant activity of the plant, though the
results are not conclusive. Other mechanisms of
action could be involved.
While many St. John's wort
products available in both the European and
American market are standardized to hypericin, this
compound has not been unequivocally linked to the
herb's antidepressant activity. While some studies
suggest that hypericin or hypericin-like compounds
may be linked to antidepressive activity, those
conclusions have recently come into question. The
active constituent is still not clearly
known.
Clinical
Studies
Early trials in 1984, showed that after taking
a standardized extract of St. John's wort, 15 women
had improvements in symptoms of anxiety including
depression, insomnia, and feelings of
worthlessness, among other indicators. This sparked
more research. Up to 1993 there had been 25
controlled clinical studies measuring the
antidepressive effectiveness of St. John's wort,
involving 1592 individual patients. Dosages ranged
between 300-900 mg of an extract (representing all
constituents in the tops of the plants), for two to
sixteen weeks in duration. Fifteen of the studies
were placebo-controlled studies and ten studies
compared St. John's wort-containing preparations
with other substances. Unfortunately, most of the
studies conducted from up to 1989 included
preparations containing both St. John's wort and
valerian. Therefore, it was not possible to
attribute any beneficial effects specifically to
one herb or the other. While these studies showed
good benefits with few or no reports of side
effects, credible clinical studies on St. John's
wort begin with trials in 1987.
A recent 1994
randomized placebo-controlled double blind study by a
psychiatrist, an internal specialist, and a general
practitioner in Austria evaluated the effect of St.
John's wort on 105 out-patients diagnosed with mild
to moderate depression or temporary depressive
moods. Patients were given the equivalent of 300 mg
of St. John's wort extract (standardized to a
hypericin content of 0.9 mg) or a placebo
preparation three times per day (900 mg per day)
for a period of 4 weeks. The results of eight
patients both in the placebo group and treatment
group were not assessed in the final results. In
the treatment group 67 percent were assessed to
respond to treatment, while only 28 percent
responded in the placebo group. Treatment group
patients were assessed as having significant
improvements in depressive mood indicators (feeling
of sadness, hopelessness, helplessness, and
uselessness), as well as emotion fear, and symptoms
of difficult or disturbed sleep. No significant
side effects were observed. These researchers
concluded that compared with synthetic
antidepressants, the St. John's wort extract
produced side effects of minor significance, and
that the extract can be recommended for the
treatment of mild and moderate depression. However,
the authors cautioned that while St. John's wort
was evaluated to be safe and effective treatment for mild to
moderate forms of depression (as determined by the
Hamilton depression scale, a standard used to
classify forms of depression), that St. John's wort
preparations were not suitable for serious
depression. Serious or severe depression can
included psychotic symptoms such as delusion,
depression with increased suicidal risk, or intense
depression that does not allow for the normal
continuation of profession or family life. In these
cases, more intensive treatment under the case of
psychiatric professionals is required.
Generally speaking,
the results of one study can only point to the need for
more studies. Scientific consensus on safety and
effectiveness is not achieved until studies are
repeated and replicated, show similar outcomes, and
involve a relatively large number of patients. To
date, there are over 20 clinical studies on St.
John's wort preparations, which can be evaluated
for results. Consequently, in 1995, E. Ernst, a
researcher with the Centre for Complementary Health
Studies and Postgraduate Medical School at the
University of Exeter authored a critical assessment
of all controlled clinical trials on the use of St.
John's wort as a treatment for depression. Ernst's
literature search revealed fourteen St. John's wort
studies conducted using a placebo for comparison,
and four studies comparing St. John's wort extracts
to standard antidepressive drugs. Analyzing the
quality of the studies using a scoring system
assessing eleven different factors, the author
concluded that eight placebo controlled studies,
and three of the four standard drug comparison
studies met the rigorous evaluative criteria. The
cumulative data of all the studies was then
evaluated, and it was concluded that St. John's
wort extract was superior to placebo in alleviating
symptoms of depression. It was also found to be
equally effective to standard medication.
Furthermore, the St. John's wort preparations had a
clear advantage over standard medications - a much
lower frequency of adverse reactions. The
conclusion - St. John's wort is a safe and
effective for symptomatic treatment of mild to
moderate forms of depression.
Hypericism
and other Cautions
It is important to note that St. John's wort
should not be taken at the same time as widely
prescribed conventional antidepressive drugs.
Monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibiting antidepressants
are not prescribed with other classes of
antidepressant drugs. Since MAO-inhibiting activity
has been linked to St. John's wort, it would be
potential dangerous in combination with
conventional, widely prescribed antidepressants
such as Prozac. Depression is a condition that
requires professional medical diagnosis and
treatment. If you are being treated for depression
and are taking or contemplating taking St. John's
wort, this treatment option should be discussed
with your health care professional, especially if
he or she has prescribed other drug
therapies.
The weed eradication
programs targeting St. John's wort are sparked in
part because of the herb's potential toxicity to
livestock, particularly sheep causing "photodermatitis" or "photo-toxicity". A condition
called "hypericism," was first recorded in 1787.
When light-skinned livestock, such as sheep, goats,
horses, and cattle ingest the plant, then are
exposed to bright sunlight, they develop welts on
the skin, and other symptoms. Dark-skinned animals
are unaffected. This photodermatitis is the result
of the interaction of sunlight and oxygen with the
pigment hypericin, after it has been ingested,
absorbed though the intestinal wall, and reaches
the blood without being eliminated by the liver or
kidneys. The photosensitization does not occur, and
has not been recorded, from external contact with
the plant by animals or humans.
This reaction has
generally not been reported in humans. Side effects
are not reported in clinical studies on using St.
John's wort for depression. The pure synthesized
compound hypericin (in assessing potential anti-HIV
activity) has caused photodermatitis in humans.
Fair-skinned individuals should be advised of the
potential problem, especially after ingesting St.
John's wort, then being exposed to bright
sunlight.
According to the German
government's official monograph on the subject, a
dose of 2-4 g of herb (0.2-1.0 mg hypericin), are
used for mild antidepressant action (MAO
inhibitor), or nervous disturbances. But remember,
depression is not like the common cold. It is not a
condition subject to self-diagnosis or
self-treatment. Therefore, professional medical
advice is essential when considering the use of St.
John's wort for the treatment of mild to moderate
forms of depression.
St.
John's Wort Oil
St. John's wort oil is used for bruises, is
anti-inflammatory, and is often used by herbalists
to help speed healing of wounds and sores. St.
John's wort oil has antiphlogistic qualities, in
other words, it helps to reduce inflammation.
Externally it is applied to bruises, sprains,
burns, skin irritations, or any laceration
accompanied by severed nerve tissue. The German
government allows such external St. John's wort
preparations to be labeled for the treatment or
after treatment of sharp or abrasive wounds,
myalgias (muscular pain) as well as first degree
burns.
This is not a
new herbal treatment, but one that has been handed down
for hundreds of years. Once known to pharmacists as "red oil" or "Hypericum liniment," it
was still available in pharmacies in the early twentieth
century. The practice of soaking the flowers in
olive oil, infusing the oil in the sun, then using
the oil internally as a diuretic and external
application for wounds dates at least to the time
of the first edition of Gerarde's Herball (1597).
It is simple to make St.
John's wort oil. The herb is harvested just as the
plant comes into bloom. Take about one cupful of
the fresh flowers, adding a sufficient quantity of
olive oil to just cover the flowers. The fresh herb
should be finely cut or crushed, covered with the
oil, then placed in the sun or warm area for two to
three weeks until the herb imparts its qualities to
the oil. Shaking it once a day helps to bring more
plant cell surfaces in contact with the menstruum,
enhancing this simple extraction process. Once the
allotted time (2-3 weeks) has passed, the herb
should be pressed, strained from the oil, then
stored in a dark, closed container in a cool
place.
The yellow flowers will
turn the oil a deep blood-red color. Basically you
are extracting the pigment, hypericin, considered
one of the biologically active compounds of the
plant, found in the flowers as little black dots
along the petal margins. It is best to use the
fresh flowers, as hypericin may degrade upon
drying. Store the oil for up to a year in a cool
dark place.
References:
- Awang, DVC. St. John's
Wort. Canadian Pharmaceutical Journal,
1991,124:33-35.
- Bombardelli, E. and P.
Morazzoni. Hypericum perforatum, Fitoterapia, 1995,
62(1):43-68.
- Crompton, C. W., I. V.
Hall, K. I. N. Jensen, and P. D. Hildebrand. The
Biology of Canadian Weeds. 83. Hypericum
perforatum L., 1988, Canadian Journal of
Plant Sciences. 68:149-62.
- Foster, S. Herbs
for Your Health, Loveland, Colorado:
Interweave Press, 1996.
- Ernst. E. St. John's
Wort, An Anti-Depressant? A Systematic,
Criteria-Based Review. Phytomedicine 1995, 2(1):67-71.
- Hahn, G. Hypericum
perforatum (St. John's Wort) - A Medicinal
Herbs Used in Antiquity and Still of Interest
Today. The Journal of Naturopathic
Medicine, 1992, 3(1):94-96.
- Harrer, G. and H.
Sommer. Treatment of Mild/Moderate Depressions
with Hypericum. Phytomedicine.
1994, 1(1):3-8.
- Hobbs, C. St. John's
Wort. HerbalGram 1988/1989,
18/19:24-33.
- Reichert, R. St.
John's Wort Extract as a Tricyclic Medication
Substitute for Mild to Moderate Depression. Quarterly Review of Natural Medicine,
1995, (Winter):275-278.
|